#1 BESTSELLING EYELINER AT CREDO

Waterproof Precision Eyeliner

Whether you're creating a subtle daytime look or a striking evening glam, this clean, refillable liner is your go-to for eyes that captivate.

4.6 stars

Lovesick

Delivery:

$21.60 today, $15.30 every refill thereafter. 

Cancel anytime. 30 day risk-free guarantee.

Shipping calculated at checkout.

4 Reasons Why You'll Love This Eyeliner

Person holding a makeup pencil near their face, showcasing eye makeup.

1. Precision Tip

For sharp, clear lines every time—effortless application meets professional finish.

Close-up of a person with eyeliner and gold hoop earring, resting their face on their hand.

2. Long-Lasting Formula

Resists smudging and fading to maintain a perfect look all day.

Orange mechanical pencil with a fine exposed tip on a plain background.

3. Waterproof Wear

Designed to withstand moisture, ensuring your eyeliner stays put, no matter the weather.

Four orange pens in a glass on a bathroom countertop.

4. Save Money & Time

Each refill uses 50% less plastic, costs 30% less than buying a new eyeliner and is delivered directly to your door.

Cruelty-free

PFA-free

Smudge-resistant

Paraben-free

Waterproof

Long-lasting

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Start saving today

Refills shipped directly to your door.

Lovesick

Delivery:

$21.60 today, $15.30 every refill thereafter. 

Cancel anytime. 30 day risk-free guarantee.

Shipping calculated at checkout.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Start saving today

Refills shipped directly to your door.

Lovesick

Delivery:

Eyeliner

$21.60 $24

Eyeliner Refill

$15.30 $17

Eyeliner

$21.60 $24

Eyeliner Refill

$15.30 $17

Waterproof Precision Eyeliner

$21.60 $24

Waterproof Precision Eyeliner Refill

$15.30 $17

NOT ALL EYELINERS ARE CREATED EQUAL

How we compare

Clean formula

Precision applicator

Staying power

Sustainable refillable design

Wearable, bold color

Other

Premium
Eyeliners

Rare

Rare

Rare

NOT ALL EYELINERS ARE CREATED EQUAL

How we compare

Clean formula

Precision applicator

Staying power

Sustainable refillable design

Wearable, bold color

Other Premium
Eyeliners

Rare

Rare

Rare

NOT ALL EYELINERS ARE CREATED EQUAL

How we compare

Clean formula

Precision applicator

Staying power

Sustainable refillable design

Wearable, bold color

Other Premium
Eyeliners

Rare

Rare

Rare

“My go-to for a flawless wing that lasts all day.”

- KATIE M.

Person winking and smiling, holding a pen near their face.

Waterproof Precision Eyeliner

Join the refill revolution

Lovesick

Delivery:

$21.60 today, $15.30 every refill thereafter. 

Cancel anytime. 30 day risk-free guarantee.

Shipping calculated at checkout.

Customer Reviews

4.6
Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
Based on 193 reviews
Total 5 star reviews: 152 Total 4 star reviews: 17 Total 3 star reviews: 14 Total 2 star reviews: 3 Total 1 star reviews: 7
193 reviews
  • DC
    Danielle C.
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Age Range 25 - 34
    Lash Length Medium
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    2 months ago
    Love

    LOVE this eyeliner!! Obsessed with the color, love the fine tip, and it lasts all day! New favorite eyeliner and I have used A LOT

  • K
    Kay
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Age Range 25 - 34
    Skin Tone Medium
    Skin Type Oily
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    4 months ago
    Literally the best eyeliner

    I’ve been wearing eyeliner for 20 years and this is by far the best eyeliner I have ever, ever used. This eyeliner lasts until I take it off before bed. It’s rich and pigmented and looks like liquid eyeliner but so much easier to apply than liquid. Doesn’t smudge or fade on my oily ass skin (looking at you, Fitglow Beauty 👀) and doesn’t irritate my eyes. I can’t say enough about this eyeliner. 10/10 will use until I die. It really doesn’t get any better than this.

  • ML
    Maria L.
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Age Range 35 - 44
    Lash Length Short
    Lash Thickness Sparse
    Skin Tone Light Medium
    Skin Type Oily
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    6 months ago
    Best eyeliner!!

    I finally found an eyeliner that works for me and doesn't smudge. It glides on really smooth. It stays put the whole day which I absolutely love. Highly recommended!

  • HS
    Hayley S.
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Age Range 25 - 34
    Skin Type Oily
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    6 months ago
    The product I’ve been looking for!

    I am a winged liner girl thru and thru…but I wanted something a little softer for every day, that would allow me to do a sharp wing without the intensity of a felt tip. This is PERFECT! I adore the color.

  • DD Profile picture for Deborah D.
    Deborah D.
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Age Range 65+
    Lash Length Medium
    Lash Thickness Average
    Skin Tone Light Medium
    Skin Type Dry
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    7 months ago
    Best!

    I have approx 25 different eyeliner pencils. Always searching for one that is waterline proof - doesn’t transfer. SOSHE is it! On top of that, the very thin pencil gives me so much more control. I’m hooked! Threw all the others in the trash. Also, the black is the first black I can truly wear that is not so harsh. Got the brown and am going to order the navy as well. BTW I’m 68.

Reviews LoadedReviews Added