On first application I really like this liner and have it in three colors. The fact that it is super thin allows me to get in close to my lashes while having a super clean line on those days when I want to keep things minimal. One complaint that I go through it very quickly because it is so thin and for the price it becomes a very expensive eyeliner. Additional it just does not wear well for me - the two picture are taken just 3.5 hours apart on a day I was working at home without exercising or anything else that would make my makeup wear off quickly. For a waterproof formula I expect it to wear longer than for it to not transfer to my eyelid (which I had powdered).

This is the best eyeliner, with the fine tip it's so easy to tight line and make a wing. This is also the first eyeliner I've ever tried that doesn't transfer on my waterline. I have back ups because I go through it so quick. Lovesick is the most perfect reddish brown shade with my blue eyes. I only wish it would last longer but I happily buy more when I'm running low cause I won't be without it.